Future of Workplace Investigations: Navigating Evolving Landscape
With the rapid advancement of technology and changing social norms, workplace investigations are becoming more complex than ever. To keep up with these changes, it's important to stay ahead of their potential impacts on future trends in this field. At Legal Cut blog we’re examining how upcoming developments could revolutionize the way lawyers conduct investigations – from embracing a broader scope of issues such as discrimination to adhering closely to laws and regulations– all while protecting their clients' interests.
So join us today for an exploration into some common challenges faced by investigators along with solutions that can help them navigate those tricky waters successfully moving forward.
The #MeToo movement has led to an increase in workplace investigations.
The #MeToo movement has sparked a new wave of sexual harassment awareness and prevention in the workplace. For example, since its rise, California employers (as well as employers in nearly every other state) have been obligated to investigate sexual harassment complaints under state law, regardless of an employee filing a formal complaint. The movement has put sexual misconduct squarely in the public eye, leading to an increase in workplace investigations among companies that want to live up to their promise of providing opportunities for all employees free from sexual harassment.
On a federal level, the EEOC reports sexual harassment claims filings have risen significantly since 2017; this is likely due to increased workforce education and employer responsiveness following the #MeToo Movement's activities. Without a doubt, the impact of this ground-breaking movement has been far-reaching and undeniably beneficial for workplaces all over the US.
The landscape of workplace investigations is constantly evolving.
The landscape of workplace investigations is always changing as new laws come into effect, businesses adapt their policies and procedures, and informal situations may arise. Even when informal methods are used to address issues in the workplace, prompt action is necessary - working with external workplace investigators or consulting a law firm with specialized knowledge in this area is crucial. And luckily, practitioners focusing on workplace investigations are also on the rise.
Employers have a responsibility to provide safe, respectful work environments for their employees. To achieve this goal, they must be mindful of legal obligations and the resources available to them when dealing with workplace issues or complaints. Professional advice can help craft efficient investigation techniques while putting everyone's rights first – creating an environment where employee concerns are addressed promptly and efficiently.
Navigating the landscape of workplace investigations can be difficult.
Navigating the landscape of workplace investigations can be a difficult and intimidating task for any experienced professional.
Fortunately, organizations like the Association of Workplace Investigators provide invaluable resources to simplify the process and give attorneys and professionals in the workplace investigation arena more confidence in their investigations. With experienced professionals pooling their knowledge and experience, they offer insights into all elements of an investigation, from interviewing witnesses to analyzing data and evidence. The Association provides key assistance when it comes to understanding today's complex workplace climates, empowering employers to go beyond just complying with regulations through their journal and also on-demand education opportunities.
(On a personal note, I found the AWI Training Institute to be invaluable in providing tools to improve my workplace investigation services and would highly recommend it to anyone interested in improving their skills. The Institute provides education on how to ethically and legally handle workplace investigations from inception through potential litigation. Happy to talk to anyone interested in attending the Institute for more details on my experience).
Here are some tips for navigating the landscape of workplace investigations:
Navigating the landscape of workplace investigations can be a tricky endeavor. It is important to approach such matters with ethics, confidentiality, and professionalism at the forefront.
The tone of voice when discussing sensitive topics should also be taken into account as it can range from professional and formal to casual and creative depending on the situation.
Ultimately, maintaining ethics and confidentiality in any context, workplace or otherwise, is essential for all types of discourse.
Understand the purpose of the investigation.
Understanding the purpose of an investigation is an important part of its successful execution. Before commencing any investigation, it's critical to define what you intend to discover and why. Knowing the objectives upfront can make it easier to develop a plan, gather necessary research and evidence, and present convincing results. Without a clear sense of its purpose, an investigation can feel aimless or even lead to irrelevant outcomes that won’t be adequately informative. Sure, some surprises may come up along the way, but having a tightly defined mission ahead of time will ensure everything goes smoothly throughout the course of your work.
But even before you begin, know the law of where you are conducting the investigation. For example, does the state where you are conducting interviews require that workplace investigations only be performed by a licensed private investigator or attorney? It is imperative that investigators have a clear sense of the legal landscape prior to commencing the investigation.
Gather as much information as possible.
A good investigator knows the importance of gathering as much information as possible. Witnesses, documents, data, and interviews should not be overlooked when examining a case closely; witnesses can provide first-hand accounts of an event, documents can offer pertinent details, data can raise questions that would never have been thought of otherwise and interviews provide further insight into relevant persons and organizations. Armed with this invaluable information, investigators are better prepared to tackle any obstacle they may face as they investigate their case.
What we expect for the future of workplace investigations: AI-focused tools, data privacy, focus on mental health and diversity, equity, and inclusion, and emphasis on alternative dispute resolution.
As companies increasingly turn to digital solutions for workplace investigations, AI-focused tools, and data privacy will continue to take center stage. This provides insight into how organizations think about protecting employees and private information. Additionally, companies are also recognizing the need to focus on mental health and diversity, equity, and inclusion as cornerstones of a successful workplace investigation process. As more organizations look at ways to proactively address potential disputes, alternative dispute resolutions increasingly come into the mix. This shift towards a more comprehensive approach gives employers assurance that any investigation is handled in a fair and accountable manner. Through these fundamental components, we can confidently move forward with the expectation that workplace investigations will occur with greater speed and accuracy.
The #MeToo movement has led to an increase in workplace investigations being conducted. However, the landscape of workplace investigations is constantly evolving, and navigating it can be difficult. Some tips for navigating the landscape of workplace investigations include understanding the purpose of the investigation and gathering as much information as possible. In the future, we expect AI-focused tools, data privacy concerns, a focus on mental health and diversity, equity and inclusion, and an emphasis on alternative dispute resolution will shape workplace investigations.
For example...
Increased Use of Technology
The workplace investigation landscape is evolving, and the adoption of automated tools to aid in investigations has been a game-changer. From AI data analysis to video surveillance software, technology gives investigators an array of powerful resources at their disposal for quickly and accurately sifting through large amounts of evidence. This helps create a swift resolution while ensuring that all aspects are properly reviewed – making the process more effective than ever before. But proceed with caution - though these tools are available for use, it doesn't always mean that they can be used. Before implementing AI tools in workplace investigations, workplace investigators should understand the legalities of such use as well as the ethical concerns in implementing them. We talk about use of AI-tools for legal professionals in another article, as well, here.
Greater Emphasis on Remote Investigations
With the rise of remote work and virtual communication, investigations may increasingly take place remotely, such as through virtual interviews and remote access to data. This can be beneficial for both employers and employees, as it allows investigations to proceed more quickly and efficiently while minimizing disruption to the workplace. Remote investigations may also promote increased participation, as employees may be more willing to cooperate in an investigation when they can do so from the comfort of their homes, which also allows them to protect their privacy (as they can provide sensitive information without having to disclose it in person).
It can also be more cost-effective for employers, especially those retaining external investigators to assist with investigations. And on that note, remote investigations give employers access to a wider pool of investigators, as it's no longer limited by geographic location (but again, be sure that your chosen investigator can legally conduct the investigation in the jurisdiction where it is taking place).
It's important to note that while remote investigations can be beneficial, they also have some limitations and challenges, such as difficulties in observing body language and facial expressions, which can be important cues in investigations.
More Focus on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)
As DEI becomes a greater focus in the workplace, investigations may increasingly focus on these issues and include specialized training for investigators on DEI-related topics. This will help ensure that investigations are conducted in a fair and impartial manner and that the rights and needs of all parties are respected.
DEI is taking center stage in the workplace and requires an extra level of care when investigating misconduct. To ensure these delicate matters are handled with fairness, impartiality, and sensitivity during investigations, special training on DEI-related topics will now be needed for investigators to fully understand their complexities. It's clear that organizations must equip their investigation teams thoroughly if they want to properly address issues of discrimination or bias in order to create a more equitable work environment.
Some examples of specialized training that investigators may receive in the future include:
Understanding unconscious bias: Training on how unconscious biases can impact investigations and how to recognize and mitigate them in the investigation process.
Cultural competency: Training on how to effectively communicate with and understand individuals from diverse backgrounds, cultures, and experiences.
Microaggressions: Training on how to recognize and address microaggressions, which are subtle forms of discrimination that can be difficult to identify and quantify.
Intersectionality: Training on how different identities and experiences intersect and can impact an investigation.
DEI-related laws and regulations: Training on the legal and regulatory requirements related to DEI, such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and recent state and local laws.
Trauma-informed investigations: Training on how to conduct investigations in a way that is sensitive to the potential trauma of the individuals involved, particularly those from marginalized groups.
Mediation and restorative justice: Training on alternative dispute resolution methods that can be used to resolve DEI-related disputes in a way that promotes healing and understanding.
By including specialized training on DEI-related topics, investigators will be better equipped to conduct investigations that are fair, impartial, and sensitive to the unique dynamics of DEI-related misconduct. This will help create a more inclusive and equitable workplace for all employees.
Increased Use of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
ADR methods such as mediation and arbitration may become more commonly used in workplace investigations as a way to resolve disputes more quickly and efficiently. ADR can be a cost-effective and less confrontational alternative to traditional courtroom litigation, and can help preserve relationships and maintain a positive work environment, including through the following:
Mediation: Mediation is a process in which a neutral third party, called a mediator, helps parties in a dispute to communicate effectively and reach a mutually acceptable resolution. In the context of workplace investigations, mediation can be used to resolve disputes related to discrimination, harassment, and other forms of misconduct.
Arbitration: Arbitration is a process in which a neutral third party, called an arbitrator, listens to the evidence and makes a binding decision about the dispute. Arbitration can be a faster and less formal process than traditional courtroom litigation and can be used to resolve disputes related to employment contracts, discrimination, and other workplace issues.
Speed: ADR methods can resolve disputes faster than traditional litigation, as they do not require the same level of formal procedures and can be scheduled more quickly.
Cost-effectiveness: ADR methods can save on legal fees and other costs associated with traditional litigation.
Privacy: ADR methods can be conducted in private, which can be beneficial for both employees and employers who may not want the details of the dispute to become public.
Preservation of relationships: ADR methods can help preserve relationships between the parties involved, as they are less confrontational and focus on finding a mutually acceptable resolution.
Tailored solutions: ADR methods can provide tailored solutions that may not be available through traditional litigation, such as mediation can offer solutions that can address the specific needs of the parties involved.
It's important to note that ADR methods may not always be appropriate, as some disputes may require the intervention of courts or regulatory agencies, but they can be an effective tool to resolve disputes in a timely, cost-effective, and private way. Employers should consider the specific circumstances of each case and weigh the pros and cons of different dispute resolution options before making a decision.
Greater Importance of Data Privacy
As more data is collected and stored during investigations, privacy, and data protection concerns will likely become more prominent. Investigations may need to comply with new regulations and laws, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union or California's Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)/California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA), to ensure that data is handled and stored securely.
Increased Use of AI-based Tools and Analytics
AI-based tools and analytics are increasingly being used to automate the investigation process. Chatbots, for example, can answer employees' questions and conduct initial screenings. This can streamline the process and help investigators focus on more complex and nuanced issues. See our article on AI-based tools for lawyers here.
Greater Emphasis on Mental Health and Well-being
As mental health has become a more prominent topic, investigations may increasingly address issues related to mental health, such as harassment and bullying, and provide support for affected parties. This can help create a more positive work environment and promote the well-being of all employees.
Emphasis on trauma-informed investigations: Investigation teams should be trained on how to conduct investigations in a way that is sensitive to the potential trauma of the individuals involved, particularly those who have been affected by harassment or bullying. This can include providing support and resources to help them cope with the stress of the investigation process.
Focus on support and healing: In addition to addressing the specific misconduct that is being investigated, investigations should also focus on providing support and resources to help affected parties heal and recover from the experience. This could include offering counseling or other forms of support.
Encourage mental health support: Employers can encourage employees to seek out mental health support and provide resources such as employee assistance programs, mental health counseling, and resources to support employees' overall well-being.
Addressing the root causes: In addition to addressing specific incidents of harassment or bullying, investigations should also focus on identifying and addressing the underlying causes of these issues, such as a toxic workplace culture or poor management practices.
Developing a prevention strategy: Employers should develop a prevention strategy that includes ongoing education and training on mental health, as well as promoting a positive work environment that supports employee well-being.
Encouraging open communication: Encouraging open communication can help create an environment where employees feel comfortable raising concerns about their mental health, and can help employers identify potential issues early on.
Include mental health experts in the investigation team: Including mental health experts, such as psychologists or counselors, in the investigation team can provide valuable insight and guidance on how to best address mental health-related issues.
It's important to note that addressing mental health in the workplace is a complex issue, and employers should work with experts in the field to develop a comprehensive approach that addresses the specific needs of their organization.
In conclusion, the field of workplace investigations is constantly evolving, and it's essential for employers and investigators to stay informed about the latest developments and trends. By understanding the changes that are taking place and adapting accordingly, employers can ensure that investigations are conducted in a fair and impartial manner and that the rights and needs of all parties are respected.
If you are wondering if a workplace situation warrants a workplace investigation or if you need guidance on how to conduct a workplace investigation, contact Wagner Legal today for a consultation. Attorney Lindsey Wagner is a Certificate Holder in Workplace Investigations from the Association of Workplace Investigators (AWI). Wagner Legal is here to help you with all your workplace investigation needs.
Don’t forget to subscribe to receive the Legal Cut, a newsletter built to keep you informed with the latest legal insights of the entertainment industry!
References:
The Association of Workplace Investigators (AWI), "Certificate in Workplace Investigations."
Wagner Legal, Workplace Investigations
